top of page

When Chargebacks Strike: A Comprehensive Guide to Disputing Them

Chargebacks are a major headache for merchants, and they can be difficult to understand. They’re also costly; in the U.S. alone, chargeback fees can cost merchants $2.4 billion each year. If you’ve been hit with a chargeback, it can feel like the odds are stacked against you. But there are steps you can take to dispute a chargeback and protect your business. This guide covers everything you need to know about disputing chargebacks, including the process, the laws that govern them, and how you can use technology to make the process easier.

What is a chargeback and why do they happen?

A chargeback is a process where a cardholder disputes a transaction and asks for a refund. Chargebacks can happen for various reasons, including fraudulent transactions, unauthorized use of a credit card, or disputes with a merchant.

Chargebacks are usually initiated by the cardholder, but the merchant can dispute them if they believe the chargeback is unfounded. Chargebacks can be costly for merchants, as they often come with additional fees and can hurt the merchant's reputation.

To prevent chargebacks from happening, merchants should have clear return policies, provide excellent customer service, and ensure that their billing descriptors are clear and accurate. In cases where a chargeback is unavoidable, merchants can dispute the chargeback by gathering evidence, building a case for dispute, and submitting a response to the acquiring bank and payment processor. By following the right steps, merchants can resolve the dispute and recover lost revenue.

The chargeback process and timeline

The chargeback process can be complex and time-consuming for merchants. It typically starts when a cardholder disputes a transaction with their issuing bank. The bank then initiates a chargeback on behalf of the cardholder and notifies the merchant. The merchant has a limited amount of time, usually 7-10 days, to respond to the chargeback and provide evidence to support their case.

Once the merchant submits their response, the acquiring bank reviews the evidence and makes a decision. This decision is then communicated to the cardholder's bank, who informs the cardholder of the outcome. If the chargeback is successfully disputed by the merchant, the funds are returned to the merchant's account. However, if the chargeback is upheld, the funds remain with the cardholder and the merchant loses the disputed amount.

The chargeback process can take anywhere from a few weeks to several months, depending on the complexity of the case and the efficiency of the banks involved. It is important for merchants to be proactive and respond promptly to chargebacks to increase their chances of a successful dispute. Additionally, merchants should keep track of the chargeback timeline and any important deadlines to ensure they don't miss any crucial steps in the process.

How to prevent chargebacks in the first place

Preventing chargebacks is crucial for merchants to minimize financial losses and maintain a good reputation. Here are some effective strategies to help merchants prevent chargebacks in the first place:

1. Clear Return and Refund Policies: Having clear and easily accessible return and refund policies can help set expectations with customers and reduce misunderstandings that may lead to chargebacks. Ensure that your policies are prominently displayed on your website, invoices, and receipts.

2. Excellent Customer Service: Providing exceptional customer service is essential in preventing chargebacks. Promptly address customer inquiries and concerns to resolve any issues before they escalate. This can include offering refunds or replacements, providing detailed product descriptions, and communicating shipping and delivery information accurately.

3. Secure Payment Processing: Utilize secure payment gateways and encryption technologies to protect customer data from fraudsters. Implement robust fraud detection systems to identify potential fraudulent transactions and take necessary precautions.

4. Accurate Billing Descriptors: Clearly label your business name and contact information on customer billing statements. Confusing or unfamiliar descriptors can lead to customer confusion and trigger chargeback requests. Make sure customers can easily recognize your charges on their statements.

5. Transaction Verification: Take steps to verify the identity of the cardholder during online transactions. Utilize additional security measures such as CVV verification, address verification systems, and 3D Secure protocols to reduce the risk of fraudulent transactions.

6. Comprehensive Order Documentation: Maintain thorough documentation of all customer orders, including transaction details, shipping records, and customer communication. This documentation can serve as evidence in case of a dispute and help support your case during a chargeback dispute.

7. Continuous Monitoring: Regularly monitor transactions and customer behavior for any suspicious activity or patterns that may indicate fraudulent behavior. Promptly investigate and take appropriate action if any anomalies are detected.

By implementing these proactive measures, merchants can significantly reduce the occurrence of chargebacks and safeguard their businesses against unnecessary financial losses and reputational damage.

Steps to take when you receive a chargeback

Receiving a chargeback can be frustrating and confusing, but there are several steps you can take to start the dispute process.

1. Review the chargeback reason and documentation: The first thing you need to do is carefully review the reason for the chargeback and any documentation provided by the issuing bank. This will help you understand why the chargeback was initiated and the evidence that supports the claim.

2. Gather evidence: Collect any relevant evidence, such as receipts, invoices, and tracking information, that supports the legitimacy of the transaction. Be sure to include any communications with the customer or evidence of their acceptance of the transaction.

3. Respond to the chargeback: The next step is to respond to the chargeback. This can usually be done through your payment processor’s online portal, and you’ll need to provide the evidence you gathered in step two. Be sure to follow all instructions carefully and provide any requested documentation in a timely manner.

4. Work with your payment processor and acquiring bank: During the dispute process, you’ll likely need to work with your payment processor and acquiring bank to provide additional information and respond to any questions or concerns they have. Be responsive and provide any requested information promptly to avoid delays.

5. Stay organized and track progress: Keep track of all documentation, communication, and progress during the dispute process. This will help you stay organized and provide a complete case if the dispute goes to arbitration.

By following these steps, you’ll be on your way to building a strong case for disputing the chargeback and recovering your lost revenue.

Gathering evidence and building a case for dispute

When a chargeback is initiated against your business, it's important to gather as much evidence as possible to build a strong case for dispute. This includes keeping detailed records of the transaction in question, including order confirmations, shipping receipts, and any communication with the customer.

Additionally, you should gather any evidence that proves the validity of the transaction and your business practices. This can include contracts, terms and conditions, customer reviews and testimonials, and any relevant industry regulations or standards.

It's also important to review your internal policies and procedures to ensure that they are compliant with industry standards and best practices. This can help you identify any potential areas of weakness in your business practices that may have contributed to the chargeback.

By gathering as much evidence as possible, you can build a compelling case for dispute and increase your chances of successfully recovering lost revenue. Remember to remain organized and keep detailed records throughout the dispute process to make it easier to present your case to the acquiring bank and payment processor.

Submitting a chargeback dispute response

Once you have gathered all the necessary evidence to build a strong case, it's time to submit a dispute response. This response will be sent to the acquiring bank and payment processor, like Diversified Payments, who will then pass it on to the issuing bank. The response should be detailed, clear, and supported by concrete evidence.

In your response, explain why the chargeback is invalid and provide evidence that supports your claim. This may include receipts, contracts, shipping confirmations, and any communication you have had with the customer. Be sure to reference the chargeback reason code and provide a detailed explanation of why the charge was valid.

It's also important to keep in mind that the response should be submitted within the allotted timeframe, typically between 10-14 days. Failing to submit the response on time can result in the chargeback being automatically decided in the customer's favor.

Submitting a chargeback dispute response requires attention to detail and a strong case. With the right evidence and attention to detail, it is possible to win the dispute and recover lost revenue.

Working with the acquiring bank and payment processor

When it comes to disputing chargebacks, it's important to have open lines of communication with both your acquiring bank and payment processor. They can provide valuable insights and guidance throughout the dispute process.

Firstly, contact your acquiring bank as soon as you receive a chargeback notification. They will often provide a chargeback response template that you can use as a guide when crafting your response. Your bank may also provide a chargeback management platform to streamline the process.

Secondly, work with your payment processor to ensure that your response includes all necessary documentation and evidence. They may also have additional resources or suggestions to strengthen your case.

Throughout the dispute process, be sure to provide timely updates and follow up on any outstanding issues. Building a strong relationship with your acquiring bank and payment processor can help streamline the dispute process and ultimately lead to a more favorable outcome. Remember to be professional and polite, and stay persistent in pursuing your dispute.

Common mistakes to avoid during the dispute process

During the chargeback dispute process, there are several common mistakes that merchants should avoid to increase their chances of a successful outcome. These mistakes include:

1. Ignoring or delaying the response: Failing to respond to the chargeback within the given timeframe can result in an automatic decision in favor of the customer. It is crucial to promptly review the chargeback, gather evidence, and submit a detailed response within the specified deadline.

2. Inadequate evidence: Insufficient evidence is a common mistake that can weaken a merchant's case. It is essential to gather and submit all relevant documentation, such as transaction records, customer communication, and shipping information, to support the validity of the transaction.

3. Lack of organization: Disputing a chargeback requires thorough record-keeping and organization. Failure to keep track of important documents, communication, and deadlines can result in missed opportunities to present a compelling case.

4. Poor communication: Ineffective communication with the acquiring bank and payment processor can hinder the dispute process. Merchants should respond promptly to any requests for additional information or clarification and provide clear, concise, and well-supported responses.

5. Not understanding reason codes: Each chargeback has a specific reason code that explains why the customer initiated the dispute. It is crucial for merchants to familiarize themselves with these reason codes to better understand the customer's claim and craft an appropriate response.

By avoiding these common mistakes and taking a proactive approach to the dispute process, merchants can increase their chances of successfully resolving chargebacks and recovering lost revenue.

Resolving the dispute and recovering lost revenue

After submitting a chargeback dispute response and gathering all the necessary evidence, the merchant can only wait for the acquiring bank's decision. If the dispute is successful, the chargeback is reversed, and the merchant receives their lost revenue back. However, if the dispute is unsuccessful, the merchant has a few options to recover lost revenue.

Firstly, the merchant can appeal the decision by providing additional evidence or by requesting a second review. This may increase their chances of a successful dispute and recovering lost revenue.

If appealing the decision is not an option, the merchant can consider debt collection or legal action. However, this option should only be considered as a last resort as it can be costly and time-consuming.

To prevent chargebacks from happening in the first place, merchants can work on improving their customer service and communication, reviewing their refund policies, and ensuring they are using a reliable payment processor like Diversified Payments, a national merchant services provider based in Texas.. In addition, merchants can also utilize chargeback management tools such as SMS authentication to help prevent fraudulent chargebacks.


bottom of page